November 18, 2026

KEPW – Whole Community News

Civic journalism from Kalapuya lands in the Upper Willamette watershed

Lisa Arkin: Why I’m supporting complete removal of dioxin-contaminated soils from Trainsong Park

7 min read
Will anyone remember what was buried in Trainsong 100 years hence?

Presenter: Through Dec. 11, you’re invited to share your comments about a proposed cleanup plan for Trainsong Park. With Part 2 in her series, longtime environmental justice advocate Lisa Arkin:

Lisa Arkin: In my first installment, titled, ‘Another Dioxin Devastation for Local Eugene Neighborhood,’ I explained the history of the discovery of serious dioxin contamination in Eugene’s Trainsong Park, and the health risks associated with exposure to dioxin.

Today I’d like to walk you through the alternatives presented in the cleanup plan proposed by the city of Eugene, including the city’s own consultants’ preferred alternative.

Then I’ll explain why I recommend one of their other alternatives.

During the period 2021 to 2026, soil testing in Trainsong Park, a busy public park, astonishingly turned up extremely high levels of the cancer-causing group of chemicals called dioxin. The levels are as much as 18 times over the health risk benchmark.

The city is legally required to protect people who use the park from getting exposed to the dioxin that permeates the soils, near swing sets and picnic tables, and a baseball field. Their consultant has posted a report and put forward different alternative cleanup plans.

Public comments and recommendations are being solicited by the city until Dec. 11.

The report posted on the city’s website is titled, ‘Analysis of Brownfield Cleanup Alternatives,’ and it actually lists four different alternatives. However, the first two, which are either doing nothing or capping the entire park with cement and fill dirt, are unacceptable. No one is recommending these choices.

That leaves either Alternative 3 or Alternative 4.

The city’s consultant prefers Alternative 4. Alternative 4 would remove up to two feet of soil from the most heavily contaminated areas and consolidate all that dirt in an engineered hill or berm inside the park’s boundaries.

These highly contaminated soils would then be covered with a geotechnical engineered fabric and then covered with two feet of clean fill dirt.

The consultant recommends this alternative because it saves money by not having to remove the dioxin-contaminated soils from the park. This choice would also use less fossil fuels by reducing the need for dump trucks to haul the dirt off site.

However, the consultants also make a strong case for Alternative 3, which would entail full excavation of all the toxic soils up to three feet below the ground surface.

The soil would be trucked offsite for disposal in a licensed landfill once all the dioxin above the health risk level has been removed from Trainsong Park. The excavated areas will be backfilled with clean imported material.

Alternative 3 provides the greatest community safety because dangerous soil would be completely removed—unlike Alternative 4, which leaves all that soil within the park.

Removal—complete removal—is extremely important because dioxin is biopersistent, which means it doesn’t degrade over time. It is a forever chemical.

Another advantage to Alternative 3 is that the city will not need to construct a giant mound of toxic dirt, so the cost of an engineered cap would not be required. That would save a considerable amount of money.

According to the consultant’s recommendation, Alternative 3 is, and I quote: ‘…is judged to have the highest level of long-term reliability because contaminated soil is permanently removed from the site.’

This action would be the best for protecting human health in perpetuity.

Both alternatives entail scraping away toxic dirt and hauling it somewhere else. The difference is that Alternative 3 hauls it away and disposes of it at a landfill designed to confine dangerous waste.

Alternative 4 excavates the worst areas of contaminated dirt and hauls it a few yards away where it stays in the park as an unsightly mound.

The report also discusses the advancing risk of climate change. The report points out that as storm events increase in magnitude, flooding and erosion at this site will also increase.

It is very important to take into consideration that Trainsong Park is located in a very low-lying area with a high water table. During wet times of the year, parts of the park are under water and natural wetlands and boggy areas are created.

Despite acknowledging these obvious advantages, the consultants ultimately recommend Alternative 4. That’s the one with the engineered mountain of toxic soils left on site.

However, if the consultant’s preferred alternative is implemented, a number of unwanted scenarios arise.

First, I believe there’s a legitimate concern that the toxic berm and its fabric cap would erode over time and dioxin-laden soils could escape.

To address this likely outcome, the city would have to create a dioxin berm repair fund to perform regular cap inspections and repair and replacement activities for all the years ahead, essentially forever.

Second, the proposed placement of this fake mountain is between the playground and the closest homes.

That’s a terrible placement because it essentially cuts off these neighbors from the park, both physically and visually.

Third, a large berm is also an attractant for vagrant activities because there will always be areas that provide a dark, unobtrusive place for someone to hang out, unseen.

And perhaps the most important consideration of all: Would you want a tall berm of toxic soils in your neighborhood park? Would you like to see children in your neighborhood playing ‘King of the Mountain’ or rolling down this toxic mountain in their summer shorts?

The DEQ states that they cannot determine how the dioxin-contaminated soil became part of Trainsong Park, but neighbors who have lived in Trainsong for many decades say that they know.

In fact, a berm of toxic dirt may actually be the dirty secret and the reason why Trainsong Park became contaminated in the first place.

As the story goes, there used to be a large berm of dirt that ran for a few blocks between J.H. Baxter on Roosevelt Boulevard and the adjacent neighborhood parallel to Coraly Street. It was ostensibly installed to block noise from the busy truck corridor and reduce odors from the chemical factory.

However, the Bethel neighborhood residents living on the other side of this dirt berm complained to the city that the berm attracted drug activities, homeless encampments and trash dumping. They demanded that the berm be removed, and it was.

Older Trainsong residents strongly believe the dirt in that berm was dumped at Trainsong Park before the city bought the property in the 1980s.

Will it ever be fully known if there is a connection between dioxin-poisoned soils dumped at Trainsong, and the J.H. Baxter chemical manufacturing plant located less than a mile away?

If true, that dirt would likely have been contaminated with dioxin from decades of pollution caused by the illegal and shoddy work practices that we now know were going on at the J.H. Baxter facility.

Let’s not forget that dioxin contamination is the reason that facility and the surrounding Bethel neighborhood are now a federal Superfund site requiring millions of dollars of cleanup work.

In September, 2025, an article published in the Lookout Eugene-Springfield online paper reported that during the 1970s, J.H. Baxter had dumped 1,400 gallons of toxic waste in an old section of Alton Baker Park that was used as a landfill.

Despite some records being kept, the chemical dumping was forgotten and the resulting contamination went undiscovered for 50 years. That is, until it was found that the chemicals were leaking into groundwater and soils adjacent to the Willamette River.

We as a community must ask: What guarantees do residents have that a similar fate of dump and forget would not occur in the future for a new berm of toxic dirt in Trainsong Park?

Will anyone remember what was buried in Trainsong 100 years hence? And will the city have the money to maintain consistent monitoring and upkeep for decades and decades to come while taking into account a predicted scenario of climate warming that will bring rainstorms and flooding?

Remember, dioxin does not degrade in soil over time. There is no go-away alternative scenario for dioxin, even after time and memory have passed us by for many decades.

I believe the choice that upholds the greatest level of public safety and public trust is Alternative 3, which would remove all contaminated soils and replace them with clean soils.

In the long run, Alternative 3 is the most cost-effective alternative, because unlike Alternative 4, it doesn’t require a budget for building a toxic berm, topping that with engineered fabric with a lifespan of about 50 years, and bringing in more dirt to create a wide mountainous high as four to six feet.

In addition, my preferred Alternative 3 would save money by not requiring funds in hand to regularly inspect, monitor, repair, and if things go awry, even remove a leaking mountain of toxic soil in a public park.

The city of Eugene is consistently beset by budget woes. Don’t we owe it to the future generations not to make this cleanup their ongoing funding burden? For the sake of community health, good governance, and the most effective environmental cleanup, let’s tell the city to choose Alternative 3 and get all of the dioxin contamination out of our public park.

To learn more, you can just Google ‘Engage Eugene’ and ‘Trainsong Park cleanup.’ There you can read the report, ‘Analysis of Brownfield Cleanup Alternatives.’ This will also be available on the KEPW.News website.

Now make sure you look at pages 21 through 26 for the maps showing soil testing results. See page 26 for the map showing the locations of the earth and berm.

Thank you, and I hope you take your time to submit public comment before Dec. 11. Send your email to Sarah.Eagle@deq.oregon.gov by 5 p.m. on Dec. 11.

Presenter: Longtime environmental justice advocate Lisa Arkin encourages you to learn more about the Trainsong Park cleanup plan and to submit public comments by 5 p.m. Dec. 11, in support of Alternative 3.


For more information:

Copyright © All rights reserved. Newsphere by AF themes.