Paul Loeb: Honor an election of change
11 min read
Presenter: Author Paul Loeb just shared a new essay on Substack titled, ‘Replace Chuck Schumer—Honor an Election of Change.’ He spoke with KEPW News Nov. 17:
Paul Loeb: I just wrote a piece about why it’s critical to replace Chuck Schumer to honor this amazing election that just passed. And why that actually includes a role for us, like calling our senators and saying, ‘Hey, it is time to replace Chuck Schumer!’
So this is my perspective on it, which is—to be candid, I’ve never been a Chuck Schumer fan. But to me, the election brings a new opportunity and it brings a sense of people voting against Trump for certain, but also for change and that’s equally important.
And so right after the election, like within two days, as soon as it was clear the Democrats were going to have a Senate majority, I started working on this piece before anybody was jumping in to oppose him, although I did say, you know, there’s a lot of senators who could be better alternatives than Chuck Schumer, Chris Van Hollen would be one of them.
Now Chris Van Hollen is the one who’s putting his hat in the ring, and so what I’ve seen, which is disturbing, is that Schumer supporters have been trying to do a kind of preemptive strike and they’re just saying, “Hey, look, he’s the Zen master. He was orchestrating the victory. How can you change when we just won this amazing victory?’
But what struck me a couple of things that I’ll talk about. One is just if he’s such a Zen master strategist, how come most of the new senators who represent so much of the party’s future almost unanimously want somebody different?
And maybe it’s ’cause they’re actually in touch with average Americans and they recognize that letting Schumer continue to symbolize the Democratic brand as majority leader insults the very direction for a different direction that powered the recent victory.
So I look at the list and this is the ones who’ve called for change. It’s Annie Andrews from South Carolina. It’s Abdul El-Sayed from Michigan. It’s Troy Jackson from Maine, Peggy Flanagan from Minnesota, Adam Hamilton from Kansas, Chris Pappas from New Hampshire, James Tallarico from Texas, Juliana Stratton from Illinois. And then Scott Colom has also raised questions from Mississippi. So that is a huge range of senators.
And what’s interesting to me is that they’re not all a certain geographic sector. They’re not all progressives. Some of them were—I mean, Hamilton was a Republican until basically about a year ago. So it’s a really wide spectrum.
You also have senators coming out opposing Schumer. You’ve got Bernie Sanders. Okay. Obviously he’s a progressive. You’ve got Raphael Warnock, he’s pretty progressive. But then you have Elissa Slotkin and Mark Warner who are as absolute sort of moderate establishment as you can get, and that’s how they would describe themselves, or at least as moderates, and they’ve got issues too.
So it’s really important that—I mean, I think Democratic unity after this victory really matters, but it’s not about just a progressive though versus moderate divide.
Even though Schumer has been on (in my view) the wrong side of issues like the Iraq war, like a lot of the banking stuff—there was a reason he was called ‘the senator from Wall Street.’
You know, the absolute embrace of Netanyahu’s policies without a tiny even bit of a demurring on that.
So I happen to personally really disapprove of a lot of his stands, but it is much, much, much larger than that. And I think it’s important that it not just get framed as, ‘Oh, well, here are some progressives out on the left flank. They don’t want Schumer.’ It really is, he’s divisive to the Democratic majority.
And the other thing is that grassroots activists don’t like him. And I had this experience this past year. I was asked to give the opening keynote at the Washington State Democratic Convention. I’d never spoken at a Democratic convention.
(I’ve never actually gone to a Democratic convention beyond my sort of precinct delegates, which is what used to be our Washington State system.)
But the chair had really liked both ‘The Impossible Will Take A Little While’ and ‘The Soul of a Citizen’ and just asked me to come in to talk about how you keep on.
I said, ‘That’s fine, but I want to raise some other issues.’ She said, ‘Whatever you want to raise is fine.’
And just to set the stage, these are volunteer activists, so they’re not paid party professionals or people who are spending their time trying to advance the Democratic Party.
And they span highly progressive Seattle districts where, you know, sometimes you’re just quibbling over stuff that may be really tiny, but, like, you’ve got to be more progressive than the next person—and then the suburbs that used to be solidly Republican, and then they’ve turned blue, and blue-collar cities like Spokane and Tacoma.
And then these conservative rural areas where if you identify as a Democrat, you might get a bullet hole through your mailbox or whatever. So it’s a really broad range.
And I’m talking with them about the possibilities and the challenges of the moment. And then I describe how Schumer, in my view, has dragged down the Democratic brand and his closeness to Wall Street and the Israel issues and how toxic that is, particularly to young voters who, you know, are a critical part of, you know, if the party has a future, it’s got to be young voters and why he needs to go.
And then I try a thought experiment. I say, ‘Okay, just think about this for a moment. Would anybody want Schumer to campaign next to you in a critical race, whether a local race, state, race, national race?’
And I really expected some argument and pushback just ’cause it’s a very diverse group and instead, which I didn’t expect, the entire room bursts into laughter and, just like every single person is cracking up. What an absurd idea.
I didn’t expect that at all, but nobody came up afterwards to say, ‘Well, you know, here’s why Schumer’s really good.’ And nobody defended him. And it was like: The emperor really does have no clothes, at least at this representative grassroots group.
So why in hell is he being even considered as the leader of the Democrats in the Senate? And so I just started thinking about, and this is why I, you know, people can go to PaulLoeb.Substack, that’s where they can see the piece or TheImpossible.org.
And I realized like he’s claiming he’s the great strategist of the Democratic victory, ‘I recruited the candidates and I got him the resources,’ and it’s actually just—it’s barely true in some parts, and it’s absolutely untrue in others.
So it’s true he helped recruit Roy Cooper and Sherrod Brown and Mary Peltola, but they weren’t exactly obscure figures hiding in a cave. Everybody else was trying to recruit them as well, because people knew they’d be really good senators. They were popular in their states. They would have a good chance.
Maybe he recruited (Josh) Turek in Iowa. You know, but again, he was a rising star and other people were trying to push him as well.
And then, you know, let’s just recognize he also backed Haley Stevens in Michigan, and Janet Mills in Maine and implicitly backed Angie Craig in Minnesota. All of ’em were really problematic candidates.
And you know, in Stevens’s case, she, you know, and the literal eve of the election, she backstabs El-Sayed and that could have cost Democrats the seat. So those were terrible choices.
And then this question is, ‘Okay, where did he allocate his resources?’ And I remember, I spent the last couple of weeks (as probably some other people did) obsessively checking on the Mississippi Senate count as Scott Colom gets, you know, more and more of a lead and eventually wins.
And he’s like, ‘Well, I recruited Colom.’ Well, maybe yes, but maybe no. And what I do know is that I, in April, I gave Scott Colom $100, which is kind of my capacity, because I thought he had a chance to win.
And I didn’t have any inside information, I’m just like, ‘Yeah, you know, I could see a possibility where it goes.’
Schumer has access to all the inside polls and the organizing and all the rest of that. He doesn’t give him any money till Oct. 20, two weeks before the election.
So, and, Colom said, well, you know, it would a lot easier if we’d gotten some resources earlier on because we didn’t have that major PAC that Schumer controls is the Senate Majority PAC. So people give to it, saying, ‘Okay, this is where we’ll coordinate and who needs money and who’s short on resources and who’s doing okay’ and all the rest of that stuff.
And it wasn’t just Scott Colom. He didn’t invest in Kansas till Oct. 9. He didn’t invest in South Carolina till five days before the election. He never invested in Louisiana where the Democrats lost by two points, even though polls showed that they were within a few points as early as July.
Didn’t invest in Florida where it was, again, less than three points. And again, polls had shown her close.
So I look at that and I think, ‘You know what? Your judgment call’s pretty crappy because yeah, you invested somewhere, but there’s a bunch of states that were really close. You didn’t give ’em any help until it was maybe too late or was too late. So that, to me, debunks the notion of the sort of great strategist.
And I also just think he’s just a terrible symbol for the party. He’s ‘only’ (quote) 75, but he’s frail. He’s a frail 75 and he is mumbling and he is stumbling and he is rambling and it just, he does not come off with a strong presence.
Some people who are older do. Bernie’s much older. Bernie’s still more vigorous.
And you know, he’s been called the senator from Wall Street, which is not what you want in a populist moment. You know, when Zohran Mamdani won the primary, you know, pick whoever he wanted in the primary, but he’s the Democratic candidate, and instead he refuses to endorse him, even though Mamdani has just finished bringing exactly the new kinds of new people into the party that the Democrats need, and that in fact showed up in November.
And so you look at that and it’s just like: ‘You’re really trying to undermine the very energy that in fact could revive this party.’
And so if you don’t have the grassroots energy, it is just instantly harder to win. And every time Schumer appears, he’s just an insult to it. Again, as I saw at the convention.
And then finally, if the Democratic brand was enormously popular, that would be one issue. But there was a NBC poll, four-five days before the election: Only 29% of the voters viewed the party favorably.
So why do you then install somebody whose approval rating nationwide is 13%? You know, a random dog could get better than that, so you just don’t want to do that.
And so to, you know, to me I look at the choice and right now, Van Hollen, who I did think would’ve been a good candidate, is a good candidate.
And to me it’s a plus that he kind of comes out of the Democratic mainstream, did the fundraising for the different committees, has ties to all the people who are sort of the old guard, but he’s also recently been really, really critical, you know, of the unflinching allegiance to Israel and the refusal to back Mamdani, and he travels to El Salvador to help build the pressure to return Kilmar Abrego Garcia.
So he is somebody with some kind of vision and courage and, that’s a good thing. So you have a kind of positive, not just a negative.
And you know, I regret that it’s a closed vote. I think it should be open. But if that’s the way it is, and they end up saying, ‘Well, you know, maybe not Schumer, but maybe not Van Hollen, here’s somebody that could unite the party,’ that’s fine with me.
I mean, even though I like Van Hollen a lot. But the challenge is, that you’ve got to honor the grassroots because the grassroots played the critical role in the victory and right now to install Schumer is just an insult to that.
And there have been groups beginning to weigh in. So Indivisible weighs in, the Machinists Union, which again, it’s interesting to me.
Machinists Union, it’s not like the international union of longshoremen. It’s not a by-its-nature radical union, it’s pretty mainstream. You know, I put ’em to the right of the steelworkers or the autoworkers.
You know, I live in Seattle, so I know that union well. Good folks. But they’re like, they can see it: This is not a good idea. Office and professional workers joined in.
So to me what I would say is that, you know, there’s going to be two weeks and basically we need to do two things. We need to call those senators. There’s two Democratic senators in Oregon as there are in my state of Washington.
And just like, okay, either TheImpossible.org or Substack Paul Loeb, and you can find the piece. (Or just ‘Chuck Schumer, Paul Loeb‘ might be the easiest way to do it.)
Send the piece over to them and then also, if you’re part of organizations that can turn around quickly, get ’em to weigh in because that matters, particularly unions that are part of the Democratic base.
So I think, to me, that does justice to what we’ve just created in this wave election. And, you know, that’s why I wrote the piece and I hope people will follow up.
Presenter: Paul Loeb just released a new edition of his classic anthology, The Impossible Will Take A Little While. You can find his writings at TheImpossible.org, or at PaulLoeb.Substack.com.
